Since my last blog post I have had a few emails from various teachers and students, each taking me to task not only for my opinions, but also for the way I have addressed things in my last blog post. Some had a good valid point that I need to clarify and some, well, some need their head to be inserted up their ass.

The one issue that was raised that I think needs a bit of attention is this – commercial teaching is not always bad and that I have generalised too much in a way that is detrimental to good teachers. This is true and the short comment in my last blog did a lot of good people a disservice while I was trying to highlight something negative that does happen on a frequent basis that is not good for magical education. My original comment was:

When a course is launched commercially, it is not in the financial interests of the teacher to not engage with or to not hand hold the student – this immediately undermines the potential of the student and does not set a path of true self discovery and development.
So let me clarify.

The trouble with writing about this issue is that it is very hard not to make generalisations and even harder to highlight all the various permutations of this issue. So let me try and be a bit clearer without having to write an epic.

Magic and magical teachers/schools, like everything else in life have various colours on the spectrum. At one end we have the purely commercial cut throat teachers/school who often do not have that much knowledge of magic, but they are usually a whizz at psychology, people manipulation, advertising, presentations and stroking egos. They run slick courses that are either widely yummy to the gullible (I can teach you to get what you want from magic) or are heavily steeped in magical ‘glamour’ with lots of robes, secrets and unintelligible teachings. They stand on high pedestals, charge large sums of money and what the student gets in return is mainly rubbish littered with some interesting magical crumbs, along with lot of hand holding and ego stroking. That is an extreme, but one that is all too common these days.pomme420

At the other end of the spectrum are teachers who work hard to produce course work

and classes for students, mentor/teach students through their magical training and charge a reasonable fee for it that pays for their time, time that they otherwise would have to be spent working to earn money in some other way. Often those fees are sensible, and enable the training to happen while also allowing the magician to provide for his or her family. Often most teachers do a mix of free work and charge for things they need to charge for. There is nothing wrong with that and it ensures the training exists: don’t forget magicians eat too, and pay rent.

 And most important of all – and the root of the comment that created the flurry of emails – if you earn your money from teaching and mentoring, which is a perfectly valid thing to do, do not fall into the trap of behaving, speaking, interacting, or teaching a student a certain way in order to ensure they continue to pay money. That, more then anything else, does a vast disservice to magic. It weakens the student, weakens the teaching and destroys the magic. If you have a student who pays well but is not a good student, is not working properly, is not capable of doing the work or is wanting you to spoon feed them, then cut them loose.lazy-student1 The right student cannot come along if your time is filled with students who are not working hard or are not truly suited to magic, and they are just playing at it; you are not teaching magic in that circumstance, you are merely taking money for giving someone attention.

These dynamics are not specific to magic, the crop up in religious teachings, the arts, music, anything really. Teach with integrity and take from it what you need in order to continue teaching if that is what you are supposed to be doing. So long as you are doing what you are supposed to be doing, the universe has an interesting way of steering resources/people to you to help you if you are truly doing what you need to do: the vessel cannot function properly if it is not resourced.

I have written at length about these issues before in my blog, and I didn’t think I needed to go over them again, but after the third teacher got in touch with me, I realised I did have to say something. I also need to get back to writing Quareia… so I will shut up now.


About Josephine McCarthy

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to Clarifying…..

  1. Fanny Fae says:

    Good teachers can be few and far between in the open market these days. The kinds of teachers that you refer to that rely on psychological manipulation, glamour and far too many slickly produced videos on YouTube don’t even fall into the same category as the legitimate ones. The adage of “When the student is ready, the teacher shall appear,” is definitely proven true in such instances. It almost becomes its own ordeal to try to find a teacher who is not going to sheer you like a sheep by taking your money and giving you little by way of instructional value.

    Conversely, as one who has taught others in the past myself, it can be incredibly depressing the amount of mollycoddling attention some students will insist upon, or ones who do not even want to do the slightest amount of work at all, and yet will expect special treatment or allowances made for them .

    I am still very excited about your course because as a student, I learned that there are teachers who are worth your time and / or money. As a teacher, I learned that there are students who are worthy of one’s time and attention as well. Unfortunately, sifting through the dross to get to the gold can be a long, arduous process. I confess, I found your books and your methods late in life and it was always good (for me) to return to the basics and strengthen the foundation that I already have and I value it very much.


    • thankyou Fanny, and wise words indeed. This is one of the things i am excited about with Quareia – they have to do the work for themselves. Once they get to the Initiate section, there will be limited mentoring available, but anyone who thinks that they can pay to be spoonfeed or mollycoddled is in for a shock! They pull their socks up and do the work or they are dropped like a hot brick. Interesting times indeed!


  2. Fanny Fae says:

    I just started the course myself and I do not intend to rush it at all. If / When I get to the Initiate portion, I know what discipline is – and would expect and hope for no less! 😉

    Lots of messages this WepRonpet from the Netjeru that yes, interesting times and definitely LOTS of changes in store!


  3. Julie says:

    I find your methods slightly different than the ones I learned years ago. I enjoy differences. They add depth, insights and strength to the practice. Like the pyramid, if the base is large, we get to the point. Remember to take care of yourself. Without you, this won’t get done.


  4. George fish says:

    Where can your email be found? I have some questions.


Comments are closed.